PA Non-Competes: What Every Employee Needs To Know!

Pennsylvania's business landscape relies on employment contracts, often including non-compete clauses. Employee mobility is significantly impacted by the enforceability of a non compete agreement in pennsylvania, a complex area governed by Pennsylvania courts' interpretation of established legal precedents. Business owners frequently use these agreements to protect confidential information, but understanding the specific requirements of a non compete agreement in pennsylvania is crucial for employees navigating their career paths.

Image taken from the YouTube channel Steve Lehto Second Channel , from the video titled Vault: Are non Compete Agreements Enforceable? .

PA Non-Competes: What Every Employee Needs To Know!

When starting a new job in Pennsylvania, or even after you've been working somewhere for a while, you might be asked to sign a document called a "non-compete agreement." This document is legally binding and can significantly impact your future career options. Understanding what these agreements are, how they work in Pennsylvania, and your rights is crucial. This explanation will help you understand the ins and outs of a non compete agreement in Pennsylvania.

What is a Non-Compete Agreement?

At its core, a non-compete agreement (also known as a covenant not to compete) is a contract that restricts an employee from working for a competing company or starting a competing business, typically for a specified period and within a specific geographic area, after leaving their current employer.

Key Elements of a Non-Compete Agreement:

• Restricted Activity: Specifies the type of work or business you are prohibited from engaging in.
• Geographic Scope: Defines the geographic area where the restriction applies (e.g., within 50 miles of Philadelphia, or throughout the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania).
• Time Period: Sets the duration of the restriction after your employment ends (e.g., for one year, or for two years).

Pennsylvania Law and Non-Compete Agreements

Pennsylvania law views non-compete agreements with a degree of scrutiny. While they are enforceable, they are not favored and must be carefully crafted to be considered valid. Courts in Pennsylvania will only enforce a non compete agreement in Pennsylvania if it is deemed reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate business interests of the employer. This means the agreement cannot be overly broad or unduly restrictive.

What Makes a Non-Compete Enforceable in Pennsylvania?

For a non-compete to be enforceable, the employer must demonstrate that it protects legitimate business interests. Legitimate business interests can include:

• Trade Secrets: Protecting confidential information that gives the employer a competitive advantage.
• Customer Relationships: Protecting relationships with established customers and preventing the employee from soliciting them after leaving.
• Goodwill: Protecting the employer's reputation and standing in the market.
• Specialized Training: Protecting substantial investment in employee training, which provides a competitive edge.

Simply preventing competition is not a legitimate business interest.

Consideration: What You Get in Return

In Pennsylvania, a non-compete agreement must be supported by "consideration." Consideration is something of value given to the employee in exchange for agreeing to the non-compete. This consideration can be:

• Initial Employment: Offering employment itself can be considered sufficient consideration if the employee signs the non-compete before starting work.
• Continued Employment + New Benefit: If the non-compete is signed after employment has already begun, continued employment alone is usually not enough. There needs to be some additional benefit offered, such as a raise, promotion, or specialized training.

Reasonableness of the Restrictions

Even if there's legitimate business interest and proper consideration, the restrictions imposed by a non compete agreement in Pennsylvania must be reasonable in terms of scope, geography, and duration.

• Scope: The restrictions must be narrowly tailored to protect the specific business interests at stake. For example, if you work in software sales, a non-compete shouldn't prevent you from working in hardware sales.
• Geography: The geographic area covered by the restriction must be related to the employer's business activities and the employee's role. A statewide restriction might be unreasonable if the employee only worked in a small region.
• Duration: The length of the restriction must be reasonable considering the nature of the business and the employee's position. Courts often look unfavorably on restrictions lasting longer than one or two years.

Common Scenarios and Examples

To illustrate how these principles work in practice, consider the following scenarios:

1. Scenario: A software engineer signs a non-compete as part of their initial employment agreement. The agreement prohibits them from working for any competing software company in Pennsylvania for two years.
   • Analysis: This could be enforceable if the employer can demonstrate that the engineer had access to trade secrets or other confidential information. The geographical scope (Pennsylvania) and duration (two years) would be scrutinized for reasonableness.
2. Scenario: A salesperson signs a non-compete after five years of employment. The non-compete prohibits them from soliciting any of their employer's customers for one year. In exchange, the employee is offered a promotion and a raise.
   • Analysis: This is more likely to be enforceable. The continued employment plus the promotion and raise provide consideration. The restriction on soliciting customers is likely a legitimate business interest, and the duration of one year is generally considered reasonable.
3. Scenario: A marketing assistant signs a non-compete agreement that prevents them from working in any marketing-related role for any company in the United States for five years.
   • Analysis: This is unlikely to be enforceable. The scope (any marketing role), geography (the entire U.S.), and duration (five years) are likely too broad and unreasonable.

What to Do if You're Presented with a Non-Compete

If your employer presents you with a non compete agreement in Pennsylvania, carefully consider the following steps:

1. Read it Carefully: Understand the exact terms of the agreement, including the restricted activities, geographic scope, and duration.
2. Negotiate the Terms: Try to negotiate the terms to make them more reasonable. For example, you might try to narrow the geographic scope or reduce the duration.
3. Seek Legal Advice: Consult with an attorney who specializes in employment law. An attorney can review the agreement, explain your rights, and advise you on the best course of action. They can also assess the likelihood that the non compete agreement in Pennsylvania would be enforced.
4. Document Everything: Keep copies of the agreement, any related documents, and all communications with your employer about the agreement.

Challenges to a Non-Compete

If you believe your non-compete agreement is unenforceable, you may be able to challenge it in court. Common grounds for challenging a non-compete include:

• Lack of Consideration: The agreement was not supported by adequate consideration.
• Unreasonable Restrictions: The restrictions are too broad in terms of scope, geography, or duration.
• No Legitimate Business Interest: The agreement does not protect a legitimate business interest of the employer.
• Public Interest: Enforcing the agreement would harm the public interest. For example, if the agreement prevents a doctor from practicing in an underserved area.

It is important to seek legal advice if you are considering challenging a non-compete.

Video: PA Non-Competes: What Every Employee Needs To Know!

Play Video